CivicFM
Sacramento

· 10 min

Council backs Railyards district expansion; members seek changes to homelessness deal

The City Council voted 8-0 to approve expanding the Railyards financing district and raising the share of its revenue set aside for affordable housing, and council members called for changes to the city-county homelessness agreement. Also: a proposed ban on selling guns from home failed to get the Planning and Design Commission's recommendation.

  1. 00:00 Headlines
  2. 00:44 Top story: Council approves Railyards financing district expansion, 8-0
  3. 03:10 Top story: Council members seek changes to city-county homelessness deal
  4. 04:47 Top story: Home gun-sales ban fails to win commission recommendation
  5. 06:33 Quick hits
  6. 09:22 Coming up
  7. 10:04 Sign-off
Follow Sacramento onYouTube

Download the MP3 · 10.1 MB

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

Transcript

Headlines

00:00

Maya This is CivicFM, with the week at Sacramento City Hall.

Maya The council approved expanding the Railyards financing district and raising the share of its revenue set aside for affordable housing. Council members want changes to the city-county homelessness agreement after a report showed it falling short on staffing. And a proposed ban on selling guns from home didn't get the Planning and Design Commission's recommendation.

Maya This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

Read more: Railyards infrastructure financing district expansion · Progress report on the city-county homelessness partnership · Proposed ban on firearm and ammunition sales as home businesses

Top story: Council approves Railyards financing district expansion, 8-0

00:44

Theo Our top story this week: on Tuesday, after more than an hour of public comment, the City Council voted to approve expanding the financing district behind the Railyards, the old rail shops between downtown and the River District.

Theo It's called an enhanced infrastructure financing district. A share of future property tax growth inside it repays streets, utilities, parks and open space. The expansion would add the Railyards West area and raise the share set aside for affordable housing from twenty to twenty-five percent of the district's net revenues. City staff called it a continuation of the deal among the city, the Railyards master developer and Sacramento Republic FC, whose stadium is under construction. Staff projected more than one hundred eighty million dollars for affordable housing over the district's life.

Maya About forty-five people spoke. Roughly twenty-five backed it, mostly business groups, building trades unions and Republic FC supporters. Roughly eighteen asked the council to wait for a community benefits agreement, among them members of Unite Here Local 49, the Central Labor Council and residents of affordable buildings in the Railyards. Here's one of them, a member of the public, on the higher set-aside.

A member of the public (from the meeting) I want to be really clear. That is not the same thing as 25% affordable housing that we have been calling for. It is a small step in the right direction, but it is not enough. It would only be 25 of the revenue left over after developers have been reimbursed.

Theo On the dais, Vice Mayor Karina Talamantes said the city would wait twenty years for its affordable housing money, until everyone else is paid, and that the deal could be better. She said she'd vote for it anyway, because she believes in the soccer dream. Mayor Kevin McCarty argued the deal has zero impact on the general fund, because it relies on future tax growth in the district.

Maya The first vote was announced eight to zero. Then Councilmember Mai Vang said she'd vote no without a timeline for staff to report back on talks with the landowners about benefits like local hiring and investment. The city manager offered to report back around the end of January, and the council voted again: eight to zero, with Councilmember Caity Maple absent, as she was all meeting.

Theo Next, the expansion goes to the Railyards district's public financing authority on December first, its final stop.

Read more: Railyards infrastructure financing district expansion

Top story: Council members seek changes to city-county homelessness deal

03:10

Maya Our second story: on Tuesday the council heard a progress report on the homelessness partnership the city and Sacramento County signed in January 2023, covering outreach, behavioral health care, shelter and housing. It took no vote. City staff said thirty-seven outreach and behavioral health workers, county clinicians among them, were deployed in the city, short of the fifty the agreement requires. Staff said the county has supplied fewer mental health workers than required, citing a clinician shortage, and hasn't opened the shelter beds it promised at a site on Watt Avenue.

Theo Councilmember Lisa Kaplan pointed out that the report called staffing above the minimum while also showing thirty-seven of fifty. Staff said that line had been carried over from the previous report. Kaplan also observed that the agreement has no consequences for missing its terms. Staff argued the standard of fifty was set when nearly twice as many people were living unsheltered as now.

Maya Kaplan asked that an updated agreement include triggers so staffing can rise if homelessness does. Mayor Pro Tem Eric Guerra asked the city manager to bring back draft amendments to share with the county, including updating the behavioral health section for Proposition 36, Senate Bill 43 and CARE Court. Councilmember Roger Dickinson said conditions have changed markedly, so it's time to revisit the agreement even with time left on it.

Theo Staff said any change needs approval from both the council and the county Board of Supervisors. No date was set for the draft amendments.

Read more: Progress report on the city-county homelessness partnership

Top story: Home gun-sales ban fails to win commission recommendation

04:47

Theo Our last top story: on Thursday the Planning and Design Commission took up a proposed ordinance that would add firearm and ammunition sales to the businesses that can't be run from a home, alongside cannabis, auto repair and adult entertainment. It came from a councilmember and a former mayor through the council's own process. The commission's role was only to recommend on the zoning change. The council decides.

Maya The zoning administrator had no exact count of home gun sellers and said staff who handle those permits recalled only a few such requests. Permits for home businesses never expire, so any already issued would stay valid. Neither the staff who led the ordinance nor the councilmember's office was there. One commissioner noted the code bars auto repair and towing from homes because they're a nuisance to neighbors. Here's that commissioner, then staff.

A commissioner (from the meeting) Adult entertainment because it could be bringing in bad actors. And then this would what would this cure?

A speaker (from the meeting) I I would defer to the council member whose proposal this is.

A commissioner (from the meeting) Fair enough.

Theo Commissioner Deborah Ortiz argued for the ban, saying gun stores have security and background checks that a neighbor's house wouldn't. The vote was five in favor and three against, with Commissioners Douglas Snell, David Nybo and Jose Goris voting no and Commissioner Erin Reschke absent.

Maya The clerk said the motion needed seven yes votes, without explaining why, and declared it failed. The commission's counsel said it can still be forwarded to the council with the votes and the commissioners' comments, and staff said the council will take it up at a future meeting.

Read more: Proposed ban on firearm and ammunition sales as home businesses

Quick hits

06:33

Maya Now a few shorter items from around City Hall. Sitting as the board of Canopy Housing, a new nonprofit affiliate for public housing, the council authorized buying the Maven on Broadway, a four-hundred-eight-unit apartment complex at Third Street and Broadway, with Ethos Real Estate. Staff said three-quarters of the units would become deed-restricted workforce housing for thirty years. The council also approved up to one hundred thirty-five million dollars in tax-exempt bonds for the purchase, which is scheduled to close next month. Since projects like this don't pay property tax for years, the mayor asked for a workshop on that exemption.

Theo The council approved digital billboards tied to the Railyards deal: three inside the Railyards, seven to one, with Councilmember Vang voting no, and a sublease for five more around the city, six to two, with Vang and Vice Mayor Talamantes voting no. The approved version requires outreach with council members whose districts contain or adjoin a billboard, and a look at glare near homes. A related funding agreement for the district also passed.

Maya On the consent calendar, the council let the city negotiate exclusively with Habitat for Humanity of Greater Sacramento over city land on Larchwood Drive, where Habitat's chief executive said about forty-three ownership homes could be built. About seven speakers supported it, and one opposed it, citing traffic near Garden Valley Elementary. The same vote raised a grant for a senior housing project on Rio Linda Boulevard. Mayor Pro Tem Guerra recused himself from that part out of an abundance of caution.

Theo From a package to speed up permitting, the council approved a program that lets the city use part of future property tax growth to subsidize affordable units in office-to-housing conversions, and matching rebates of up to ten thousand dollars for small businesses making accessibility improvements. It also adopted an ordinance allowing pre-approved home designs, amended so the approved plans expire after five years.

Maya About six people at Tuesday's public comment asked the city to revoke a by-right permit for a crematory across from D.W. Babcock Elementary. Councilmember Dickinson said the city attorney had advised that the city has no discretion to deny it, and he'll ask for a formal opinion. The air quality district plans a neighborhood hearing, likely in December. On Thursday, Planning and Design Commission Vice Chair Dov Kadin asked staff to consider, in a zoning update coming in January, requiring a conditional use permit for uses like crematoriums.

Theo And Mayor McCarty reported on his trip with a twenty-nine-member delegation to Matsuyama, Japan, a sister city whose ties with Sacramento go back forty-five years.

Read more: Canopy Housing board: first meeting and purchase of the Maven on Broadway apartments · Up to $135 million in Housing Authority bonds for the Maven on Broadway · Digital billboards inside the Railyards · Citywide digital billboard sublease with Indomitable Ventures · 2026 master funding agreement for the Railyards financing district · Consent calendar, including Habitat for Humanity negotiating rights on Larchwood Drive land and a larger Rio Linda senior Homekey+ grant · Adaptive reuse investment incentive program (AB 507) · Small business accessibility rebate program · Registered house plans ordinance, with a five-year expiration added · Public comment on matters not on the agenda, and responses · Commission's 2026 annual report · Council comments: sister city trip and immigration enforcement

Coming up

09:22

Theo Before we go, a look at what's ahead. Next Tuesday at two, the council meets jointly with the county Board of Supervisors on an independent assessment of SHRA, the housing agency. Staff recommend keeping SHRA's joint powers authority intact and developing options for how it's governed.

Maya At five that evening, the agenda includes a short-term rental ordinance that needs a two-thirds vote, written objections to proposed water and wastewater rates for 2027 through 2031, a pilot crew to take on illegal dumping, and a police contract with Axon of up to about seventeen and a half million dollars.

Sign-off

10:04

Maya If you hear something we got wrong, there's a link on the episode's page to tell us, and corrections are read on air.

Maya That's the news from City Hall. See you after the next meeting.

What happened

City Council Tuesday, November 10

20 items

The meeting's page · The recording · Agenda

Veterans Day recognition Item B

The council honored local veterans ahead of Veterans Day with a resolution, joined by representatives of local veterans organizations. 00:02:20

G.I.R.L.S. Rock Sacramento 10th anniversary Item A

The council presented a resolution marking ten years of G.I.R.L.S. Rock Sacramento, which offers music education and mentoring to girls and trans, nonbinary and gender-expansive youth. 00:08:56

Consent calendar, including Habitat for Humanity negotiating rights on Larchwood Drive land and a larger Rio Linda senior Homekey+ grant

Affordable housingHomelessnessStreet safety

Items 1 through 20 were approved in one vote. They include an exclusive right to negotiate with Habitat for Humanity of Greater Sacramento over possible sale of city land at 3630 Larchwood Drive, south of Patio Avenue (item 3), where Habitat's CEO said about 43 ownership homes for households under 80% of area median income could be built; an $18,903,309 increase (to $19,689,400) in the city's grant agreement with Urban Capital, LLC for the Rio Linda Senior Homekey+ project (item 2, which needed a two-thirds vote); acceptance of the flood control agency's 2026 levee progress report (item 11); and a construction contract and related agreements to rebuild the Lampasas Avenue and Rio Linda Boulevard intersection (item 13). 00:11:51

  • Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) moved to approve the consent calendar (items 1–20), seconded by Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2); Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) recused on item 2; Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed. Recused: Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem). 00:31:23
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) praised progress in the flood protection report on item 11, noting the Natomas basin is ringed by 42 miles of levees, and urged residents to report clogged gutters to 311 before El Niño rains. 00:12:19
  • A councilmember thanked staff for item 13, saying the Lampasas Avenue and Rio Linda Boulevard intersection confuses drivers and is unsafe for pedestrians and cyclists. 00:13:13
  • A councilmember moved the consent calendar and highlighted item 3, a surplus-land partnership with Habitat for Humanity to build ownership homes, acknowledging traffic and school drop-off concerns and recalling her own family's self-help housing experience. 00:14:03
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) commended Habitat for Humanity for building ownership homes on hard-to-develop vacant lots, citing a past project off Power Inn Road and Glen Elder. 00:29:17
  • A councilmember responded to recent online accusations of Levine Act violations over item 2, saying she had looked into them, had not accepted money from the individual for over a year, and the other allegations had no merit under the law. 00:30:39
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) said he would recuse himself from item 2 out of an abundance of caution. 00:31:04

Canopy Housing board: first meeting and purchase of the Maven on Broadway apartments

Affordable housingBonds and debt
The Maven on Broadway, a 408-unit apartment complex completed in 2023 at 3rd Street and Broadway, with its resort-style pool and community clubhouse.
The Maven on Broadway, a 408-unit apartment complex completed in 2023 at 3rd Street and Broadway, with its resort-style pool and community clubhouse. Shown at the City Council, Nov 10 · 00:33:18

Sitting as the board of Canopy Housing, Inc., a newly incorporated public housing nonprofit affiliate, the council ratified the new corporation's founding actions and authorized it to partner with Ethos Real Estate to buy the Maven on Broadway, a 408-unit apartment complex at 3rd Street and Broadway in District 4. Staff said 306 units (75%) would become deed-restricted workforce housing for 30 years, 82 of them for households up to 50% of area median income and 224 up to 80%, with 102 units staying market rate. The purchase would be financed with tax-exempt bonds, and the property would not pay property tax for a number of years. 00:31:33

  • Sitting as the board of Canopy Housing, Inc., Phil Pluckebaum (Councilmember, District 4) moved staff's recommendation, adopting the board's resolutions ratifying first-meeting organizational actions and authorizing acquisition and financing of the Maven on Broadway with Ethos Real Estate; seconded; the clerk announced Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) and Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) absent. Result: passed. 00:40:50
  • SHRA staff described the property as a 408-unit Class A complex completed in 2023 at 3rd Street and Broadway, with one- and two-bedroom units and amenities. 00:33:10
  • SHRA staff said Canopy would pay about $261,000 per unit and convert 306 units, 75% of the total, to deed-restricted workforce housing for 30 years. 00:34:03
  • SHRA staff said 82 units would serve households up to 50% of area median income (up to $46,000 for one person) and 224 units households up to 80% (up to $73,600 for one person). 00:34:03
  • SHRA staff said 102 units, a quarter of the total, would remain at market-rate rents to keep a mixed-income community. 00:36:05
  • SHRA staff said a pledge of SHRA's unencumbered general revenues is expected to result in a two to two and a half percent reduction in the bonds' interest rate. 00:39:14
  • The mayor noted after the vote that such projects do not pay property tax for years and asked for a near-future workshop on the welfare-exemption policy, the new state law and long-term budget impacts. 00:40:53
  • Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) welcomed the workshop and said the city should explore state-level policy changes so local jurisdictions still receive some revenue from tax-exempt projects. 00:41:42

Up to $135 million in Housing Authority bonds for the Maven on Broadway Item 22

Affordable housingBonds and debt

A Tax Equity and Fiscal Responsibility Act (TEFRA) public hearing and approval for the Housing Authority to issue up to $135 million in tax-exempt 501(c)(3) bonds to finance Canopy Housing's purchase of the Maven on Broadway, with a 30-year regulatory agreement to keep units affordable. The agenda states the developer pays all fees and the city and Housing Authority have no obligation beyond issuing the bonds. 00:42:06

  • Phil Pluckebaum (Councilmember, District 4) moved to close the public hearing and adopt the City Council and Housing Authority resolutions authorizing up to $135 million in tax-exempt bonds for the Maven on Broadway; seconded; Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed. 00:45:00
  • SHRA staff described the property as 8.7 acres with twelve three-story residential buildings, a single-story building and a parking structure, needing no major rehabilitation now. 00:42:36
  • SHRA staff said the financing funds a capital account for future rehab, a twelve-month operating reserve and capitalized interest, and that the purchase is scheduled to close next month. 00:43:40
  • Phil Pluckebaum (Councilmember, District 4) called the bond issuance a significant milestone for the region's affordable housing and moved the item. 00:44:27

SHRA's 2027 budget Item 21

BudgetsAffordable housingFederal and state funding
A chart of the Housing Choice Voucher program's housing assistance payment budget, which grew from about $154.6 million in 2023 to a proposed $243 million for 2027, roughly 57% in four years.
A chart of the Housing Choice Voucher program's housing assistance payment budget, which grew from about $154.6 million in 2023 to a proposed $243 million for 2027, roughly 57% in four years. Shown at the City Council, Nov 10 · 00:50:31

Approval of the Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Agency's 2027 budget, about $361.9 million, and the city Housing Authority's budget, plus a loan and bond application schedule. About $243 million goes to rental assistance payments under the Housing Choice Voucher program, which under the proposed budget would be about 57% above 2023's while federal funding lags; county public housing faces an operating shortfall. 00:45:06

  • Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) moved to close the public hearing and adopt the City Council and Housing Authority resolutions approving the 2027 SHRA and Housing Authority budgets and the loan and bond application schedule; Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) seconded and, presiding, called the vote; Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5), Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) and Kevin McCarty (Mayor) absent. Result: passed. 01:09:03
  • SHRA staff presented a proposed 2027 agency budget of about $361.9 million in expenditures, about two-thirds of it rental assistance payments. 00:46:39
  • SHRA staff said housing assistance payments rose from about $154.6 million in 2023 to a proposed $243 million in 2027, driven by rising rents rather than more households served. 00:49:49
  • SHRA staff said services and supplies spending rises 74% to $33.6 million, largely to speed up unit turnover, while capital spending falls about 34% after large projects closed out. 00:51:53
  • SHRA staff said the county's 645-unit public housing portfolio lacks enough operating funding and faces a deficit, unlike the city's portfolio of about 1,257 units. 00:57:02
  • SHRA staff warned that under the federal continuing resolution next year's funding is unknown until at least December 11. 00:58:23
  • SHRA staff said SHRA, like about 60% of housing agencies nationally, got a 0% inflation factor, adding to its voucher shortfall. 00:59:25
  • SHRA staff reported SHRA had closed all 17 of its federal recovery action items and that HUD third-party inspections scored its properties between 89 and 99. 01:02:39
  • SHRA staff reported 2026 approvals of $225.5 million in mortgage revenue bond financing across five developments and $25.4 million in multifamily loans across seven. 01:04:42
  • Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) urged early discussion of the CDBG project selection process so the limited money goes to the neediest parts of the city, then moved the budget. 01:07:15
  • A councilmember seconded and announced that an assessment of SHRA would be presented at a city-county meeting the following Tuesday. 01:09:03

Progress report on the city-county homelessness partnership Item 23

HomelessnessMental health and addiction

A report on whether the city and Sacramento County are meeting the terms of their homelessness partnership agreement, covering outreach, behavioral health services, shelter and housing, and training. Staff reported the city is short of required outreach staffing (37 versus 50), the county has supplied 8 of the 10 required mental health workers and has not opened a promised 200-bed site on Watt Avenue, and shelter capacity has grown over 60% since 2022. Council members called for changes to the agreement. 01:09:58

▶ Hear it Is the city meeting its homeless outreach staffing requirement? · 0:55

  • Report received and filed; no vote taken. Result: no action. 01:52:49
  • City staff said the agreement was signed in January 2023 and is about a year from expiring, can be extended five years by mutual agreement, and can only be changed by both the council and county supervisors. 01:10:13
  • City staff said the city fields 14 encampment teams that call on behavioral health clinicians as needed, and has shifted clinicians into shelters where they are more effective. 01:12:17
  • City staff said the county supplied only eight of the ten mental health workers required, citing a clinician shortage. 01:13:19
  • City staff said the county's commitment to open 200 more beds within 36 months, at the Watt Avenue site, has not been met. 01:15:24
  • City staff said outreach and behavioral health staff fell from 54 in the second half of 2025 to 37, partly because the HOPE outreach contract was not renewed, in line with a drop in unsheltered people. 01:16:28
  • City staff said shelter bed capacity has grown more than 60% since 2022 with about 95% utilization. 01:19:37
  • City staff said more than 1,500 permanent supportive housing beds have been created during the agreement. 01:20:42
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) pointed out that the report says staffing is above the minimum but also that only 37 of the required 50 outreach staff were deployed. 01:24:53
  • City staff said the above-minimum language was carried over from the prior report and the city is under the required 50. 01:25:43
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) observed that the agreement has no consequences for missing its terms. 01:27:09
  • City staff argued the staffing standard of 50 was set when about 4,400 people were unsheltered, versus about 2,400 now. 01:27:17
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) asked that an updated agreement include triggers allowing staffing to flex if homelessness rises again. 01:29:04
  • City staff said outreach teams work with River City Waterway Alliance and will be in Steelhead Creek several days next week ahead of the rains. 01:31:19
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) asked whether the Fire Department would be included in a revised agreement. 01:32:58
  • City staff recommended adding public safety, both fire and police, to the agreement. 01:33:49
  • Phil Pluckebaum (Councilmember, District 4) called for a second core center beyond the one downtown, including support for people released from jail. 01:34:51
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) asked the city manager to bring back draft amendments to the agreement to share with the county. 01:35:33
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) asked that the behavioral health section, which cites only Laura's Law, be updated for Prop 36, SB 43 and CARE Court. 01:36:37
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) proposed trigger language letting the city manager and county executive amend the agreement as state laws change without returning to both boards. 01:36:37
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) asked that the agreement require the city and county to identify their highest utilizers of services, noting the last county report was from 2016. 01:37:39
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) asked to write into the agreement the new city-county-hospital multidisciplinary task force. 01:38:41
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) asked to formalize regular meetings of the legal agencies involved in conservatorship and to add accountability mechanisms. 01:39:41
  • Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) said it is time to revisit the agreement even if it has time left to run, because conditions have changed markedly. 01:41:34
  • Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) warned that people cleared from creeks without shelter move into neighborhoods, business areas and parks. 01:42:42
  • City staff said the main limit is shelter capacity, not getting people to accept shelter, and that 35 new beds at Roseville Road open next week. 01:45:17
  • Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) called for aligning outreach with available capacity and for more focus on prevention. 01:47:01
  • City staff said staff will bring forward a prevention program working with school districts to connect families in need to resources. 01:48:00
  • A councilmember argued that people with severe addiction or mental illness should be moved more quickly toward LPS conservatorship once in shelter, and urged urgency. 01:48:31
  • A councilmember asked how much of the outreach and services staffing is paid from the general fund, and was told the outreach is general fund. 01:51:12
  • A councilmember stressed that the city is not a health and human services agency, so the county partnership is essential. 01:51:45

Streamline Sacramento strategic action plan Item 24

Housing supplySmall business

An update on the city's effort to make building and business permitting faster and cheaper, presented together with four related actions (items 25–28) heard in one presentation and voted separately. Staff reported 57 potential actions tracked, recent changes such as moving small-project review to the online portal, dropping the optional ADU zoning review fee and launching a building inspection phone line, and upcoming work on review times, demolition procedures and a concierge service for applicants. 01:53:13

▶ Hear it Will pre-approved house plans leave wheelchair users at the curb? · 0:46

  • City staff said the initiative began as a mayor and council priority and is now part of the city's One City, One Future work plan. 01:54:05
  • City staff said the program's actions table tracks 57 actions generated from community input. 01:56:10
  • City staff listed recent changes, including eliminating the optional ADU zoning review fee. 01:56:10
  • City staff said a plan review cycle-time study should finish in fall 2026, with updated times published as early as January 2027. 02:03:49
  • City staff said a concierge service has started with introductory emails and a formal program is planned for 2027. 02:04:53
  • The mayor said streamlining was a priority from his first day as mayor and that the city should grow its economy rather than cut services. 02:19:49
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) asked for a one-stop contact and a flyer residents can use to find planning and permit help. 02:22:57
  • A councilmember said the cost of money is now the biggest hurdle for housing and called for regional, equitable funding of affordable housing. 02:26:49
  • A councilmember asked how a parcel map waiver for splits of one to four lots saves three months. 02:28:07
  • City staff explained that eligible final maps skip the council agenda routing, which takes about three months. 02:29:10
  • City staff clarified that tentative maps still require a public hearing with notice and council members are notified; the change only affects final maps. 02:31:50
  • A councilmember asked whether the concierge service resembles the old red team for big projects. 02:32:23
  • City staff described the concierge as a friendly early contact for applicants, with a second phase to be developed with the incoming economic development director. 02:33:27
  • A councilmember urged that all relevant departments, including public works and fire, be in the room with applicants. 02:34:25
  • Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) cited a business owner blocked by a 2008 rule from demolishing a fire-damaged building, which the package's demolition reforms address. 02:37:12
  • The mayor credited Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) with proposing the demolition reform. 02:38:31
  • A councilmember asked that the concierge service treat immigrant and first-time small business owners with care and tact. 02:40:02

Adaptive reuse investment incentive program (AB 507) Item 25

Housing supplyAffordable housing

Creates a program under Assembly Bill 507 that lets the city use part of the future property tax growth from projects converting office or commercial buildings into housing to subsidize those projects' required affordable units. Each funding request must come back to the council, and payments can run up to 30 years after a project is occupied. 02:41:31

  • Kevin McCarty (Mayor) moved to adopt the resolution establishing the Adaptive Reuse Investment Incentive Program; Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) seconded; Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed. 02:41:57
  • City staff explained the program uses part of future property tax revenue generated by a qualifying conversion to subsidize its affordable units. 01:57:16
  • City staff said approved incentive payments can last up to 30 years, starting the fiscal year after a certificate of occupancy. 01:58:23
  • A councilmember called himself a strong advocate of adaptive reuse and said easing it will bring more such housing. 02:35:40

Small business accessibility rebate program Item 26

Small businessSeniors and disability

Approves guidelines for rebates to small businesses and commercial property owners for disability-access improvements, paid from a state-mandated fee on business licenses that the city keeps in an accessibility fund. Staff said $134,500 is reserved, eligible applicants could get up to $10,000 in matching funds, and the general fund is not affected. 02:42:01

  • Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) moved to approve the Small Business Accessibility Rebate Program guidelines and let the City Manager amend them within the program's purpose; Kevin McCarty (Mayor) seconded; Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed. 02:42:13
  • City staff said state law requires a fee, now $4, on business licenses, with 90% kept by the city in an accessibility compliance fund. 02:02:46
  • City staff said $134,500 has been reserved for rebates, with part of future revenue to be added. 02:02:46
  • City staff said eligible businesses and property owners could receive up to $10,000 in matching funds. 02:02:46
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) supported the program, saying some businesses have closed because they could not afford to comply with accessibility rules. 02:24:22

Registered house plans ordinance, with a five-year expiration added Item 27

Housing supplyZoning and plans

Changes the zoning code so pre-approved, repeatable home designs (registered house plans) are approved by staff rather than the Planning and Design Commission, aiming to cut review time and cost. After a mix-up over which item it belonged to, the council rescinded its first vote and readopted the ordinance with an amendment that a registered house plan expires after five years. 02:42:23

  • Motion by Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1), seconded by Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2), to close the hearing and adopt the registered house plans ordinance as posted (later rescinded); Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed. 02:42:50
  • Motion to rescind the earlier vote on item 27 (mover not clearly identified); Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed. 02:44:24
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) moved to close the hearing and adopt the registered house plans ordinance amended so that a registered house plan expires after five years; seconded (seconder not identified); Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed. 02:45:07
  • City staff said the ordinance moves approval of registered house plans from the Planning and Design Commission to staff. 02:01:36
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) proposed that approved registered house plans expire after five years so they are reviewed again as codes change. 02:25:23
  • City staff pointed out that the five-year amendment belonged to the registered house plans item, not the omnibus. 02:43:30

2026 zoning code omnibus: ADUs, demolitions, adaptive reuse Item 28

Zoning and plansHousing supply

A bundle of planning code changes to match 2025 state laws, streamline approvals and clean up the code. It sets up the state's streamlined checklist for office-to-housing conversions, clarifies accessory dwelling unit rules (per the agenda, staff's edits allow two local detached ADUs per lot with a combined maximum of 1,600 square feet; staff said these are in addition to two ADUs and one junior ADU under state law), and widens exemptions from design review for demolishing older or fire-destroyed accessory structures. 02:42:56

  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) moved to approve item 28 with the five-year registered house plan expiration amendment, which belonged to item 27. Result: withdrawn. 02:43:36
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) moved to close the hearing and adopt the omnibus ordinance as proposed, without her amendment, including staff's ADU edits to section 23; seconded by Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7); Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed. 02:44:08
  • City staff said the amendments clarify that two locally allowed ADUs plus two ADUs and one junior ADU under state law are permitted. 02:00:31
  • City staff said the demolition exemption would expand to accessory structures over 50 years old or destroyed by fire or disaster. 02:00:31
  • A councilmember responding to a public comment on crematoriums, said the zoning code should require a conditional use permit for them and that he will pursue that in the zoning code amendment process early next year. 02:35:40

Railyards infrastructure financing district expansion Item 29

Bonds and debtEconomic developmentAffordable housing
A map of the new boundaries proposed in the 2026 Railyards EIFD expansion.
A map of the new boundaries proposed in the 2026 Railyards EIFD expansion. Shown at the City Council, Nov 10 · 02:52:56

Expands the Railyards Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District to add the Railyards West area and amends its infrastructure financing plan, letting a share of future property tax growth there repay infrastructure such as streets, utilities, parks and open space; the set-aside for affordable housing rises from 20% to 25% of net district revenues. Staff described it as a continuation of the 2024 term sheet and the 2025 comprehensive project agreement among the city, the Railyards master developer and Sacramento Republic FC, whose 20,000-seat stadium is under construction; the master developer's chief executive called the expansion the agreement's final major step. Staff projected over $180 million for affordable housing over the district's life; Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) and speakers urging delay said that money comes last, after others are paid. The 2016 development agreement's affordable-unit floor, cited as 6%, is unchanged. Dozens of speakers split between support and calls to delay for a community benefits agreement. 02:50:31

▶ Hear it Is a 25% set-aside the same as 25% affordable housing? · 0:47

  • Kevin McCarty (Mayor) moved to adopt the resolution expanding the Railyards EIFD and amending the infrastructure financing plan, including raising the affordable housing set-aside from 20% to 25% of net EIFD revenues, with direction to staff to work with the landowners on increased local investment and partnerships and return to council; seconded by Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7). A first vote was announced 8-0; Mai Vang (Councilmember, District 8) then said she would vote no without a timeline for staff to report back, Maraskeshia Smith (City Manager) offered a report-back around the end of January, and the vote was retaken; Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 06:02:40
  • City staff said the deal brings more than $325 million in upfront private investment and could support over 13,000 jobs. 02:53:28
  • City staff said nearly 500 Railyards units have been built so far, 44% of them deed-restricted affordable. 02:53:28
  • City staff said the district is expected to generate over $180 million for affordable housing with the 25% set-aside. 02:53:28
  • The city's financing consultant presented the city's fiscal analysis estimating a general fund surplus of about $362,000 a year in the initial phase and about $3.4 million a year at build-out. 02:57:55
  • The city's financing consultant said the city's commitment would draw about $95 million more in private infrastructure spending, which developers advance and bear the risk on. 02:59:00
  • The Railyards master developer's chief executive said the developer has built 495 units, 219 of them affordable, and is entitling a 300-unit project. 03:01:40
  • Wilton Rancheria's chairman said the tribe kept investing in the stadium during delays and asked the city to keep its commitment. 03:20:10
  • City staff said that if approved, the expansion goes next to the Railyards EIFD public financing authority on December 1. 03:24:34
  • City staff said the financing plan does not fund a parking garage; a 1,200-stall garage is only a land-use assumption and a footnote leaves it open for study, with no amount committed. 04:48:48
  • City staff explained the 6% figure comes from the 2016 development agreement and is a variable floor tied to total units. 04:50:42
  • City staff said the 6% refers to a share of housing units while the 25% refers to a share of district revenues, so the two are not comparable. 04:52:39
  • The Railyards master developer's chief executive said housing demand should rise once the anchor projects open, but construction timing depends on the market. 04:55:39
  • The mayor argued the deal has no impact on the general fund because it relies on future tax growth in the district. 04:57:26
  • The mayor asked staff, the developer, Wilton and the Republic to keep working on local investment and good-paying union jobs, outside the motion. 04:59:48
  • Phil Pluckebaum (Councilmember, District 4) argued that saying no is the easy, safe choice and that the project itself is the community benefit. 05:00:26
  • A councilmember said he sympathizes with calls for more affordable housing, local hire and labor representation but cannot attach them to an already negotiated deal tonight. 05:08:45
  • A councilmember asked for ways to deliver affordable housing money sooner than the late 2030s. 05:09:46
  • A councilmember objected that the new district boundary drew out existing residents who had been inside it, which staff confirmed. 05:11:46
  • A councilmember called for a Railyards for everyone, not just the wealthy, with union jobs. 05:12:47
  • A councilmember said the deal should include a community benefits agreement like Aggie Square's. 05:17:00
  • Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) argued affordable housing money arriving twenty years from now, after others are paid, is not enough, and that the deal could be better. 05:19:05
  • Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) said she would vote for the district expansion because she believes in the soccer project. 05:20:07
  • Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) asked the developer why housing cannot be built now. 05:22:13
  • The Railyards master developer's chief executive answered that the urban rental market is soft because so much housing was recently built. 05:22:33
  • Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) asked staff to bring a list of potential partners for added community benefits to the December 1 financing authority meeting. 05:26:16
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) asked whether anything in the specific plan prevents negotiating more affordable housing; staff said no, the 2016 strategy sets a floor. 05:29:31
  • City staff confirmed the mixed-income strategy sets only a floor for affordable housing. 05:30:29
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) suggested a mobile fresh food market, costing about $10,000 a year, for residents in the food desert until a store opens. 05:34:15
  • City staff committed to meeting with Railyards residents at least once a year. 05:35:49
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) said the council should not use its power on the Railyards vote as retribution for not getting what one wants in another city. 05:39:19
  • The city manager noted the new state affordable housing bond as a tool the city could pair with district revenue. 05:40:28
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) said Aggie Square's benefits came from steady negotiation, not imposition. 05:42:10
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) pointed to the staff report's revenue projections showing little district revenue until about project year 11. 05:43:10
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) asked the developer and Wilton Rancheria to commit to working with the mayor's office on a local hiring and local investment plan. 05:45:12
  • The Railyards master developer's chief executive said the developer is open to talks on local hiring but not ready to commit to metrics or zip codes. 05:48:17
  • Wilton Rancheria's chairman committed the tribe to sitting down to discuss local hiring. 05:49:54
  • The mayor floated, outside the motion, prioritizing Railyards projects for state housing bond money and keeping housing trust fund fees generated there in the Railyards. 05:57:00
  • The city manager said staff would talk with the partners and report back, but a December timeline was not realistic. 06:00:34
  • A councilmember said she would vote no without a timeline for staff to report back; after a report-back at the end of January was agreed, the vote was retaken. 06:01:38

Motion to extend the meeting past 9 p.m.

A procedural vote to let the meeting continue past 9 p.m. 04:47:37

  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) moved to continue the meeting past 9 p.m.; seconded; Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed. 04:47:48

Digital billboards inside the Railyards Item 30

Economic development

Directs the City Manager or a designee to sign the first amendment to the city's master lease for digital billboards with Downtown Railyard Venture, LLC, adding details for three sign locations within the Railyards, with a finding that the billboards meet city sign code criteria. 06:02:56

  • Motion to approve the first amendment to the Railyards master lease for digital billboards (mover not clearly identified), seconded by Phil Pluckebaum (Councilmember, District 4); Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed, 7-1. No: Mai Vang (Councilmember, District 8). 06:03:20
  • A councilmember said she wants the long-delayed citywide billboard market study in hand before voting on billboards. 05:17:00
  • Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) said she would support the billboards inside the Railyards district but not the citywide ones. 05:26:16

Citywide digital billboard sublease with Indomitable Ventures Item 31

Economic development

A master sublease letting Indomitable Ventures, LLC operate five digital billboards at sites around the city, including on Reclamation District 1000 land, part of the Railyards deal's financing. Some council members objected that the city's billboard revenue study is still pending and that locations were disclosed only days before the vote. The approved motion adds requirements for outreach with affected council offices and design review of glare near homes. 06:03:47

  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) moved to approve the master sublease with Indomitable Ventures, LLC, amended to require the applicant to coordinate community outreach with each council member whose district contains or adjoins a billboard, and to have design review consider light glare, light source and orientation for billboards within 400 feet of residential buildings; seconded; Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed, 6-2. No: Mai Vang (Councilmember, District 8), Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor). 06:05:16
  • City staff corrected the staff report: three billboards are 14 by 48 feet and two are 25 by 48 feet, reviewed under a different sign code section. 03:24:34
  • A councilmember asked how new billboards would affect revenue from billboards the city already earns money from. 05:01:16
  • City staff said a consultant's billboard market study draft is expected to reach staff in December before going to the council. 05:02:10
  • A councilmember recalled that billboards were a modest part of a 2006 Railyards arena financing plan and cautioned against expecting a windfall. 05:03:38
  • Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) said she would vote no on the citywide billboards because locations were disclosed only last week, including one on RD1000 land in her district. 05:26:16
  • Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) offered her own rough estimate, not a staff figure, that 12 billboards at about $250,000 a year over 35 years would be worth about $105 million. 05:28:24
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) asked that the applicant coordinate with council members whose districts contain or adjoin billboards. 05:52:39
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) asked that design review consider glare, light source and orientation for billboards near homes. 05:52:39
  • City staff read into the record that the recommendation should cite city code section 15.148.965.D.5.a through e. 06:03:53

2026 master funding agreement for the Railyards financing district Item 32

Bonds and debtEconomic development

Authorizes the City Manager or a designee to sign the 2026 master funding agreement for the Railyards Enhanced Infrastructure Financing District among Downtown Railyard Venture, LLC, Indomitable Ventures, LLC, the Railyards EIFD and the city; staff said it carries the 25% affordable housing set-aside. 06:05:52

  • Motion by Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2), seconded by Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor), to adopt the resolution authorizing the 2026 Master Funding Agreement; no noes were heard, and Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) was absent (the result was announced as eight to one with one absent, which can't add up). Result: passed. 06:06:04

CalPERS contract amendment ordinance continued to December 1 Item 33

Pay and pensions

An ordinance amending the city's contract with the California Public Employees' Retirement System, passed for publication October 13 and continued from October 27, was continued again to December 1, 2026, as staff recommended. 06:06:31

  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) moved to continue the item to December 1, 2026, as staff recommended; seconded (seconder not identified); Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: continued. 06:07:04

Council comments: sister city trip and immigration enforcement

ImmigrantsSchools and education

Kevin McCarty (Mayor) reported on a delegation trip to sister city Matsuyama, Japan, and asked city staff to share what the city knows about federal immigration enforcement with school districts. 06:07:29

  • The mayor reported representing Sacramento on a 29-member delegation to Matsuyama, a sister city relationship going back 45 years, focused on cultural, education and economic exchanges. 06:08:38
  • The mayor asked the city manager to communicate the city's information and policies on ICE actions to school districts across the city. 06:09:47

Public comment on matters not on the agenda, and responses

PollutionDevelopment projects

About 20 people spoke on items not on the agenda, chiefly a by-right crematory permit across from DW Babcock Elementary, proposed data centers, the closure of the public counter at the Kinney police station in Del Paso Heights, and immigration enforcement's effect on students. Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) responded on the crematory and the counter. 06:10:49

  • A councilmember told a school board trustee he did not believe the council had received the district's resolution opposing the crematory. 06:19:56
  • Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) said the city attorney had advised that the city has no discretion to deny the crematory because it is a by-right use. 06:55:05
  • Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) said he will ask the city attorney for a formal opinion that addresses the general plan and environmental points speakers raised. 06:56:06
  • Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) said the air quality district's environmental analysis of the crematory is nearly done and it will hold a public hearing in the neighborhood, likely in December. 06:56:06
  • Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) said he had asked the city manager and police chief to reconsider closing the public counter at the Kinney police station. 06:57:10

Public comment

  • Consent calendar: about eight people spoke. About seven, including Habitat for Humanity's CEO, neighborhood association leaders, a neighborhood nonprofit director and residents of Northgate and Gardenland, supported item 3, the Habitat for Humanity negotiations for about 43 ownership homes on long-vacant Larchwood Drive land. One opposed it, citing traffic on Northgate Boulevard near Garden Valley Elementary, asthma, parking and limited community engagement.
  • Consent item 2: one phone caller raised Levine Act concerns over campaign contributions from people tied to Urban Capital to Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) and Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1), objected to fast-tracking the grant increase, and questioned the lack of competitive selection and parts of the project budget.
  • Homelessness partnership report (item 23): one speaker objected to treating homelessness mainly as a behavioral health problem and to plans for an involuntary-care pathway, citing the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act, and asked that involuntary criteria come to the council publicly with disabled people involved.
  • Streamline Sacramento (items 24–28): seven spoke. Five representatives of business, development and construction groups supported the package, with requests to include nonprofit-led projects and commercial tenant improvements in faster reviews. One urged fixing a zoning conflict that allows crematories by right near homes and schools. One disability advocate said the accessibility rebate program does not require a certified access specialist and the registered house plans ordinance has no access standard for the path from sidewalk to door.
  • Railyards items (29–32): 61 people signed up and about 45 spoke. Roughly 25 supported the financing district, mostly business chambers, downtown and Midtown districts, Visit Sacramento, building trades unions and apprentices, Republic FC supporters, and Reclamation District 1000, which would collect rent from one billboard site. Roughly 18 urged delaying the votes for a community benefits agreement, among them Unite Here Local 49 members, the Central Labor Council, the Railyards for All coalition, residents of affordable buildings in the Railyards, and housing advocates. They called for 25% affordable housing, an anti-displacement fund, a grocery store and living-wage jobs, and several criticized Wilton Rancheria over a union dispute at Sky River Casino. Two speakers asked the council to drop possible reimbursement of a parking garage of about $60 million.
  • Non-agenda public comment: about 20 spoke. About six, including a Twin Rivers school trustee, a Babcock kindergarten teacher and a neighborhood association president, demanded the city revoke the by-right permit for two crematory incinerators at 2445 Albatross Way across from DW Babcock Elementary and help pay for air monitoring. About six opposed proposed data centers, at Depot Park and in McClellan, citing water, power, noise and pollution, and asked for a moratorium. Four objected to closing the public counter at the Kinney police station in Del Paso Heights. Two school leaders described immigration enforcement's toll on students and asked for a confirmed meeting with the city. One said the city's agenda documents are not accessible to blind residents.

What's next

  • The Railyards EIFD expansion, infrastructure financing plan and master funding agreement go to the Railyards EIFD Public Financing Authority on December 1.
  • Staff are to meet with the Railyards landowners (the master developer, Wilton Rancheria and Republic FC) on local hiring, local investment and other community benefits, and Maraskeshia Smith (City Manager) agreed to report back around the end of January, possibly in the City Manager's report.
  • Karina Talamantes (Councilmember, District 3; Vice Mayor) asked staff to bring a list of potential partners for added Railyards benefits to the December 1 financing authority meeting.
  • Staff committed to meeting with Railyards residents at least once a year.
  • A draft of the consultant's citywide billboard market study is expected to reach staff in December; no council date was given.
  • Kevin McCarty (Mayor) floated, outside the motion, prioritizing Railyards projects for state housing bond money and keeping Railyards housing trust fund fees in the Railyards.
  • Kevin McCarty (Mayor) asked for a workshop soon on the welfare property tax exemption for nonprofit-owned housing and its budget impact.
  • The Maven on Broadway purchase is scheduled to close next month.
  • An SHRA assessment will be presented at a city-county meeting the following Tuesday, November 17.
  • SHRA said federal funding remains uncertain until at least December 11, when the continuing resolution is next up.
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) asked the city manager to bring back draft amendments to the city-county homelessness partnership agreement to share with the county; staff said they will bring a homelessness prevention program with school districts.
  • Outreach teams plan several days in Steelhead Creek the following week, when 35 shelter beds at Roseville Road open.
  • Plan review cycle-time study due fall 2026, with updated cycle times as early as January 2027; a formal concierge program is planned for 2027.
  • Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) will pursue requiring a conditional use permit for crematories in the zoning code amendment process early next year, and will ask the city attorney for a formal opinion on the Albatross Way crematory.
  • The air quality district plans a neighborhood public hearing on the crematory, likely in December.
  • Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) asked the city manager and police chief to reconsider closing the Kinney police station public counter.
  • The CalPERS contract amendment ordinance (item 33) returns December 1, 2026.
  • Kevin McCarty (Mayor) asked the city manager to share ICE enforcement information and policies with school districts.

Write to the City Council before its next meeting: its comment form

Planning and Design Commission Thursday, November 12

9 items

The meeting's page · The recording · Agenda

Certificates of service for three commissioners whose terms are expiring

The city clerk's office thanked Larry Lee (Commissioner), Douglas Snell (Commissioner) and Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) for their service on the commission and handed out certificates of service, as this was the last regular meeting before their current terms expire. 00:02:36

Planning director's report

Housing supply

The planning director's regular update to the commission on recent council actions and the commission's schedule. 00:03:53

  • The planning director reported that the council last Tuesday adopted a registered house plans ordinance allowing pre-approved home designs, as part of a larger streamlining initiative, along with another ordinance whose name was garbled in the recording 00:04:13
  • The planning director noted this was the commission's last meeting of the year, with the next meeting on January 14 00:04:13

Consent calendar: approval of commission minutes Item 1

Routine approval of the commission's minutes; the agenda listed the minutes of October 8 and October 22, 2026. Counsel suggested approving the October 8 minutes now and the October 22 minutes at a later meeting, once commissioners had seen them, and the chair agreed; the motion didn't say which minutes it approved. 00:04:45

  • Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) moved to approve the minutes; Douglas Snell (Commissioner) seconded; Erin Reschke (Commissioner) was absent. Result: passed. 00:06:36
  • A commissioner pointed out that the posted report contained only the October 8 minutes and not the October 22 minutes 00:05:07
  • The commission's counsel suggested the October 22 minutes could be attached to the next staff report and approved once commissioners had seen them 00:05:32
  • The commission's counsel advised a commissioner who missed the last meeting that there was no need to abstain, since approving minutes attests to the clerk's work 00:05:56

Norwood Avenue gas station alcohol sales permit withdrawn Item 2

Development projectsSmall business

A request for a conditional use permit to sell beer, wine and distilled spirits under a Type 21 off-sale license at an existing gas station convenience store at 4200 Norwood Avenue in District 2, on about 0.71 acres in the General Commercial zone (agenda). City staff recommended denial (agenda). The item had been continued from October 22, 2026. 00:06:54

  • No vote; the applicant withdrew the application at the hearing. Result: withdrawn. 00:07:53
  • City staff told the commission the applicant wanted to ask for a second continuance 00:07:21
  • A project applicant said that instead of a continuance they would withdraw the application, work with the community and the police department, and reapply later 00:07:34
  • City staff explained that with the withdrawal there would be no project, and the applicant would have to file a new conditional use permit request later 00:07:53

Humble Root cannabis manufacturing, distribution and delivery permits on Otto Circle Item 3

CannabisDevelopment projects

Two conditional use permits, one for cannabis production (manufacturing and distribution) and one for a delivery-only cannabis dispensary, in an existing vacant building at 197 Otto Circle (agenda) in District 5, on a 0.46-acre parcel in the Light Industrial zone and Executive Airport Overlay zone. Staff said the commission had to review it because the site is within 600 feet of two faith congregations and a storefront dispensary. 00:08:14

  • Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) moved to approve the staff recommendation: the CEQA exemption and both conditional use permits; Jose Goris (Commissioner) seconded; Erin Reschke (Commissioner) was absent. Result: passed. 00:16:58
  • City staff described the request as a cannabis micro business doing distribution, manufacturing and delivery-only sales in an existing 5,200-square-foot building 00:08:53
  • City staff said commission review was required because the site is within 600 feet of three sensitive uses 00:08:53
  • City staff noted no cultivation or storefront sales are proposed, and that the site had a cannabis production permit approved in 2018 whose operator surrendered its permits 00:09:53
  • City staff reported that notices went to owners and residents within 500 feet and no public comment letters had been received 00:09:53
  • A project applicant said the facility would not be open to the public and would support about 40 employees 00:12:19
  • A project applicant said the business currently fills about 150 orders a day with five delivery vehicles and batches routes, and expects similar activity at the site 00:12:19
  • A project applicant said the two nearby churches were visited and raised no concerns 00:12:19
  • A commissioner asked the applicant to explain what a micro business is 00:14:07
  • A project applicant explained that a micro business license lets a small business run delivery, manufacturing and distribution under one license 00:14:15
  • A commissioner asked about odor control, noting the staff report did not address it and odor is a common neighbor complaint 00:14:49
  • A project applicant answered that air scrubbers left by the prior operator remain, doors stay closed, and no cultivation or curing will occur, which is where most odor comes from 00:15:09
  • The vice chair moved approval, praising the applicant's efforts to be a good neighbor 00:16:21

Proposed ban on firearm and ammunition sales as home businesses Item 4

Zoning and plansSmall business

An ordinance proposed through the council's rules-of-procedure process by a councilmember and a former mayor would add firearm and ammunition sales to the list of businesses that may not be run from a home, under the zoning code (Title 17). The same ordinance also amends business provisions in Title 5, which staff said is for the council alone; the commission's role was only to recommend on the zoning change. The council makes the final decision at a future hearing. 00:17:23

▶ Hear it What problem would banning home gun sales solve? · 0:31

  • Larry Lee (Commissioner) moved the staff recommendation (CEQA exemption and recommending the council adopt the Title 17 amendment prohibiting firearm and ammunition sales as home occupations), with commissioners' comments compiled and forwarded to the council; Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) seconded; Erin Reschke (Commissioner) was absent. Result: failed, 5-3. No: Douglas Snell (Commissioner), David Nybo (Commissioner), Jose Goris (Commissioner). 00:56:40
  • The zoning administrator explained the proposal came through the council's rules of procedure, was reviewed by the Law and Legislation Committee, and would add firearm and ammunition sales to the prohibited home businesses, alongside cannabis 00:19:10
  • The zoning administrator said the commission's role is only to recommend on the Title 17 zoning amendment, with the Title 5 portion included for administrative efficiency 00:20:13
  • Douglas Snell (Commissioner) asked how many home businesses currently sell firearms or ammunition 00:20:56
  • The zoning administrator said there was no exact count, staff recalled only a few such requests, and the city processed over a thousand home occupation permits last year 00:21:05
  • A commissioner raised concern about a liability insurance requirement for gun owners, citing affordability for neighbors in District 8 00:21:53
  • The zoning administrator replied that the insurance question falls under the Title 5 portion for the council, but the concern would be passed on 00:22:45
  • Deborah Ortiz (Commissioner) got staff's confirmation that personal gun ownership is unaffected, and voiced full support for prohibiting home sales, suspecting unpermitted sales occur 00:23:48
  • Deborah Ortiz (Commissioner) asked whether a 1996 city ordinance requiring gun dealers to register with police and stay away from sensitive places is still enforced, and asked staff to follow up 00:23:48
  • The zoning administrator said commercial firearm sellers must locate in commercial zones and, depending on the zone, need a commission-level conditional use permit 00:25:29
  • A commissioner noted the 2024 council memo had proposed much more, including a $25 fee and insurance for all gun owners, and that it had been scaled back 00:27:22
  • The zoning administrator said discussions between city departments and the councilmember had narrowed the original request 00:28:15
  • The zoning administrator said federal licensing is outside the department's expertise, and that an attorney from the city attorney's office who had intended to attend in support was not there 00:29:25
  • The zoning administrator said the ban would apply going forward and existing home occupation permits never expire, so any already issued would stay valid 00:30:51
  • The zoning administrator said unpermitted home sellers found by the city's two zoning investigators would have to stop if the ordinance passes 00:32:08
  • The commission's counsel said they believed a federal license is also needed to sell firearms 00:33:32
  • A commissioner described buying a hunting firearm from a home dealer and then having to complete paperwork, a test and a wait at a licensed dealer, and asked whether the ban would double up on that process 00:34:37
  • Douglas Snell (Commissioner) asked whether any incidents were tied to firearms legally sold by home businesses 00:35:47
  • A commissioner argued the ban is appropriate policy but would not reach unlicensed sales happening under the radar 00:38:32
  • A commissioner said they were uncomfortable voting given unanswered questions and suggested someone from the sponsoring councilmember's office return to explain 00:39:46
  • The zoning administrator said the staff who led the ordinance and the councilmember's office were not present, despite the office being informed of the meeting 00:40:52
  • The zoning administrator listed current prohibited home businesses: auto repair, tow service, cannabis and adult entertainment 00:42:39
  • David Nybo (Commissioner) noted existing bans address neighbor nuisances and asked what problem this ban would solve 00:43:07
  • The planning director explained the item came to the commission because city code requires its review of Title 17 changes 00:44:30
  • The commission's counsel advised the commission could decline to vote and simply forward its comments 00:44:54
  • Douglas Snell (Commissioner) said there was not enough information on licensing or on the problem the ban is meant to solve 00:45:27
  • Deborah Ortiz (Commissioner) argued commercial gun stores have security and background checks that a neighbor's house selling firearms would not, and that buyers would still have options 00:48:19
  • Larry Lee (Commissioner) supported the item and noted it does not cover unfinished firearm components such as ghost guns or printed parts 00:49:13
  • The vice chair supported the staff recommendation, saying the commission routinely decides where uses are appropriate 00:50:11
  • The zoning administrator said a home firearm-sales permit request today would go to the zoning administrator, reaching the commission only on appeal 00:51:02
  • The chair recalled an accidental discharge at a gun store and said wood-frame houses offer little protection, favoring the ban while describing themself as a responsible gun owner 00:51:49
  • The commission's counsel said a motion would be preferable to forwarding without a recommendation 00:52:48
  • A commissioner voted yes, in support of barring home sales even without full information on federal rules 00:53:28
  • Douglas Snell (Commissioner) voted no, saying it was unclear the ban solves a current problem 00:54:11
  • David Nybo (Commissioner) voted no, calling gun sales heavily regulated and seeing no demonstrated problem 00:54:49
  • A commissioner voted no, agreeing with the policy direction but saying the city must provide better information before such decisions 00:55:42
  • The city clerk stated that the motion needed seven aye votes to pass 00:56:21
  • The commission's counsel said the item can be forwarded to the council with the votes and the commission's comments 00:56:48

Commission's 2026 annual report Item 5

Zoning and plansWarehouses and industryPollution

The commission's annual report to the council and public on its accomplishments and priorities, forwarded to the council's Personnel and Public Employees Committee. The 2027 Planning and Zoning Work Program is attached as an appendix once the council adopts it. Discussion turned to a crematorium approved by right near an elementary school. 00:56:58

  • Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) moved to forward the 2026 annual report to the Personnel and Public Employees Committee; Douglas Snell (Commissioner) seconded; Erin Reschke (Commissioner) was absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 01:14:04
  • The planning director presented the second version of the report, with project numbers updated since the October 8 review 00:58:00
  • The planning director said the chair's message is still being written and the work program will be added as appendix A after council action 00:58:00
  • A commissioner asked whether the crematorium's by-right status comes from city or state law 01:03:30
  • The planning director said crematoriums are allowed by right in the M-1 and M-2 industrial zones 01:04:00
  • The planning director said a crematorium rule could be added to the comprehensive zoning code update coming to the commission in January 01:05:03
  • A commissioner urged ways to notify the public or involve community associations when industrial uses locate next to homes 01:05:41
  • Deborah Ortiz (Commissioner) asked what tools exist to block future crematoriums near schools 01:06:50
  • The planning director said requiring a conditional use permit for crematoriums would add a discretionary review guided by environmental justice policies 01:08:50
  • The planning director said a broader review of land uses and health would need data the city plans to collect starting next year 01:08:50
  • Deborah Ortiz (Commissioner) expressed concern about polluting uses being concentrated in some communities and asked that this be considered in future zoning changes 01:10:25
  • David Nybo (Commissioner) thanked the public speaker for well-prepared comments 01:11:04
  • The vice chair moved the staff recommendation and asked staff to raise switching such uses from by right to conditional use permits in the January presentation 01:11:25
  • The planning director said the annual report can move forward separately, with the work program going to Law and Legislation and then the council in late January 01:12:26

2027 Planning and Zoning Work Program Item 6

Zoning and plans

The yearly list of planning and zoning policy priorities and action items, which the council approves each year. The commission recommends it to the council, expected in late January. 01:14:26

  • David Nybo (Commissioner) moved the staff recommendation to forward the 2027 Planning and Zoning Work Program to the council for approval; Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) seconded; Erin Reschke (Commissioner) was absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 01:20:11
  • The planning director said a staff report attachment summarizes and responds to the commission's October comments 01:14:40
  • The planning director said no substantive changes were made to the work program since the October meeting 01:15:40

Commissioner comments

Commissioners' closing remarks, including thanks to a commissioner whose term is ending. 01:20:20

  • David Nybo (Commissioner) thanked a fellow commissioner for their service 01:20:40
  • A commissioner clarified that the certificate marks the end of a term and said they expect to be scheduled for another term next year 01:20:52

Public comment

  • One member of the public spoke on the annual report (agenda item 5) in opposition because the 2027 work program will be attached to it. They argued the work program leaves out the general plan's environmental justice policies. They cited a crematory with two incinerators approved by right in August 2025 across from D.W. Babcock School, and said pollution burden in the census tract has risen.
  • The same speaker returned on the 2027 work program (agenda item 6). They argued a conditional use permit requirement would be inadequate. They said the zoning code bars crematories from many zones and near transit sites, yet one was approved about 400 feet from the school.
  • During comment on matters not on the agenda, the same speaker urged the city to revoke the administrative by-right approval of two incinerators at 2445 Albatross Way before a certificate of occupancy is issued. They cited zoning code and general plan provisions.
  • No members of the public spoke on the consent calendar, the Humble Root permits, or the firearm ordinance.

What's next

  • The firearm and ammunition home-sales ordinance goes to the council at a future hearing. Counsel said it can be forwarded with the commission's votes and comments, and staff said the council can still adopt it.
  • Staff said the insurance concern and the question of whether any incidents are tied to firearms sold legally from homes would be passed to the council.
  • Staff agreed to follow up with Deborah Ortiz (Commissioner) on whether gun dealers are registering with the police department under an older city ordinance.
  • The 2026 annual report goes to the council's Personnel and Public Employees Committee, then to the council.
  • The 2027 Planning and Zoning Work Program goes to the Law and Legislation Committee, then to the council in late January.
  • The comprehensive zoning code update comes to the commission in January. Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) (moving agenda item 5) asked staff to include whether some uses, such as crematoriums, should need a conditional use permit instead of being allowed by right.
  • The Norwood Avenue applicant may reapply later with a new conditional use permit request.
  • The next commission meeting is January 14.

Write to the Planning and Design Commission before its next meeting: its comment form

Coming up

Every claim is checked against the recordings and documents linked above. Report an error · Transcript (WebVTT) · Download the MP3

Embed this episode

Paste this into a post on WordPress, Ghost, or any site that takes HTML. On WordPress, pasting this page's address works too.

<iframe src="https://sacramento.civic.fm/embed/episodes/2026-11-14" width="640" height="160" style="border:0;max-width:100%" title="Council backs Railyards district expansion; members seek changes to homelessness deal · Sacramento" loading="lazy"></iframe>