· 9 items
Planning and Design Commission, Thursday, November 12
On the episode: Council backs Railyards district expansion; members seek changes to homelessness deal
This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.
What happened
Planning and Design Commission Thursday, November 12
9 items
Certificates of service for three commissioners whose terms are expiring
The city clerk's office thanked Larry Lee (Commissioner), Douglas Snell (Commissioner) and Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) for their service on the commission and handed out certificates of service, as this was the last regular meeting before their current terms expire. 00:02:36
Planning director's report
Housing supply
The planning director's regular update to the commission on recent council actions and the commission's schedule. 00:03:53
- The planning director reported that the council last Tuesday adopted a registered house plans ordinance allowing pre-approved home designs, as part of a larger streamlining initiative, along with another ordinance whose name was garbled in the recording 00:04:13
- The planning director noted this was the commission's last meeting of the year, with the next meeting on January 14 00:04:13
Consent calendar: approval of commission minutes Item 1
Routine approval of the commission's minutes; the agenda listed the minutes of October 8 and October 22, 2026. Counsel suggested approving the October 8 minutes now and the October 22 minutes at a later meeting, once commissioners had seen them, and the chair agreed; the motion didn't say which minutes it approved. 00:04:45
- Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) moved to approve the minutes; Douglas Snell (Commissioner) seconded; Erin Reschke (Commissioner) was absent. Result: passed. 00:06:36
- A commissioner pointed out that the posted report contained only the October 8 minutes and not the October 22 minutes 00:05:07
- The commission's counsel suggested the October 22 minutes could be attached to the next staff report and approved once commissioners had seen them 00:05:32
- The commission's counsel advised a commissioner who missed the last meeting that there was no need to abstain, since approving minutes attests to the clerk's work 00:05:56
Norwood Avenue gas station alcohol sales permit withdrawn Item 2
Development projects
A request for a conditional use permit to sell beer, wine and distilled spirits under a Type 21 off-sale license at an existing gas station convenience store at 4200 Norwood Avenue in District 2, on about 0.71 acres in the General Commercial zone (agenda). City staff recommended denial (agenda). The item had been continued from October 22, 2026. 00:06:54
- No vote; the applicant withdrew the application at the hearing. Result: withdrawn. 00:07:53
- City staff told the commission the applicant wanted to ask for a second continuance 00:07:21
- A project applicant said that instead of a continuance they would withdraw the application, work with the community and the police department, and reapply later 00:07:34
- City staff explained that with the withdrawal there would be no project, and the applicant would have to file a new conditional use permit request later 00:07:53
Humble Root cannabis manufacturing, distribution and delivery permits on Otto Circle Item 3
CannabisDevelopment projects
Two conditional use permits, one for cannabis production (manufacturing and distribution) and one for a delivery-only cannabis dispensary, in an existing vacant building at 197 Otto Circle (agenda) in District 5, on a 0.46-acre parcel in the Light Industrial zone and Executive Airport Overlay zone. Staff said the commission had to review it because the site is within 600 feet of two faith congregations and a storefront dispensary. 00:08:14
- Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) moved to approve the staff recommendation: the CEQA exemption and both conditional use permits; Jose Goris (Commissioner) seconded; Erin Reschke (Commissioner) was absent. Result: passed. 00:16:58
- City staff described the request as a cannabis micro business doing distribution, manufacturing and delivery-only sales in an existing 5,200-square-foot building 00:08:53
- City staff said commission review was required because the site is within 600 feet of three sensitive uses 00:08:53
- City staff noted no cultivation or storefront sales are proposed, and that the site had a cannabis production permit approved in 2018 whose operator surrendered its permits 00:09:53
- City staff reported that notices went to owners and residents within 500 feet and no public comment letters had been received 00:09:53
- A project applicant said the facility would not be open to the public and would support about 40 employees 00:12:19
- A project applicant said the business currently fills about 150 orders a day with five delivery vehicles and batches routes, and expects similar activity at the site 00:12:19
- A project applicant said the two nearby churches were visited and raised no concerns 00:12:19
- A commissioner asked the applicant to explain what a micro business is 00:14:07
- A project applicant explained that a micro business license lets a small business run delivery, manufacturing and distribution under one license 00:14:15
- A commissioner asked about odor control, noting the staff report did not address it and odor is a common neighbor complaint 00:14:49
- A project applicant answered that air scrubbers left by the prior operator remain, doors stay closed, and no cultivation or curing will occur, which is where most odor comes from 00:15:09
- The vice chair moved approval, praising the applicant's efforts to be a good neighbor 00:16:21
Proposed ban on firearm and ammunition sales as home businesses Item 4
Zoning and plansSmall business
An ordinance proposed through the council's rules-of-procedure process by a councilmember and a former mayor would add firearm and ammunition sales to the list of businesses that may not be run from a home, under the zoning code (Title 17). The same ordinance also amends business provisions in Title 5, which staff said is for the council alone; the commission's role was only to recommend on the zoning change. The council makes the final decision at a future hearing. 00:17:23
▶ Hear it What problem would banning home gun sales solve? · 0:31
- Larry Lee (Commissioner) moved the staff recommendation (CEQA exemption and recommending the council adopt the Title 17 amendment prohibiting firearm and ammunition sales as home occupations), with commissioners' comments compiled and forwarded to the council; Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) seconded; Erin Reschke (Commissioner) was absent. Result: failed, 5-3. No: Douglas Snell (Commissioner), David Nybo (Commissioner), Jose Goris (Commissioner). 00:56:40
- The zoning administrator explained the proposal came through the council's rules of procedure, was reviewed by the Law and Legislation Committee, and would add firearm and ammunition sales to the prohibited home businesses, alongside cannabis 00:19:10
- The zoning administrator said the commission's role is only to recommend on the Title 17 zoning amendment, with the Title 5 portion included for administrative efficiency 00:20:13
- Douglas Snell (Commissioner) asked how many home businesses currently sell firearms or ammunition 00:20:56
- The zoning administrator said there was no exact count, staff recalled only a few such requests, and the city processed over a thousand home occupation permits last year 00:21:05
- A commissioner raised concern about a liability insurance requirement for gun owners, citing affordability for neighbors in District 8 00:21:53
- The zoning administrator replied that the insurance question falls under the Title 5 portion for the council, but the concern would be passed on 00:22:45
- Deborah Ortiz (Commissioner) got staff's confirmation that personal gun ownership is unaffected, and voiced full support for prohibiting home sales, suspecting unpermitted sales occur 00:23:48
- Deborah Ortiz (Commissioner) asked whether a 1996 city ordinance requiring gun dealers to register with police and stay away from sensitive places is still enforced, and asked staff to follow up 00:23:48
- The zoning administrator said commercial firearm sellers must locate in commercial zones and, depending on the zone, need a commission-level conditional use permit 00:25:29
- A commissioner noted the 2024 council memo had proposed much more, including a $25 fee and insurance for all gun owners, and that it had been scaled back 00:27:22
- The zoning administrator said discussions between city departments and the councilmember had narrowed the original request 00:28:15
- The zoning administrator said federal licensing is outside the department's expertise, and that an attorney from the city attorney's office who had intended to attend in support was not there 00:29:25
- The zoning administrator said the ban would apply going forward and existing home occupation permits never expire, so any already issued would stay valid 00:30:51
- The zoning administrator said unpermitted home sellers found by the city's two zoning investigators would have to stop if the ordinance passes 00:32:08
- The commission's counsel said they believed a federal license is also needed to sell firearms 00:33:32
- A commissioner described buying a hunting firearm from a home dealer and then having to complete paperwork, a test and a wait at a licensed dealer, and asked whether the ban would double up on that process 00:34:37
- Douglas Snell (Commissioner) asked whether any incidents were tied to firearms legally sold by home businesses 00:35:47
- A commissioner argued the ban is appropriate policy but would not reach unlicensed sales happening under the radar 00:38:32
- A commissioner said they were uncomfortable voting given unanswered questions and suggested someone from the sponsoring councilmember's office return to explain 00:39:46
- The zoning administrator said the staff who led the ordinance and the councilmember's office were not present, despite the office being informed of the meeting 00:40:52
- The zoning administrator listed current prohibited home businesses: auto repair, tow service, cannabis and adult entertainment 00:42:39
- David Nybo (Commissioner) noted existing bans address neighbor nuisances and asked what problem this ban would solve 00:43:07
- The planning director explained the item came to the commission because city code requires its review of Title 17 changes 00:44:30
- The commission's counsel advised the commission could decline to vote and simply forward its comments 00:44:54
- Douglas Snell (Commissioner) said there was not enough information on licensing or on the problem the ban is meant to solve 00:45:27
- Deborah Ortiz (Commissioner) argued commercial gun stores have security and background checks that a neighbor's house selling firearms would not, and that buyers would still have options 00:48:19
- Larry Lee (Commissioner) supported the item and noted it does not cover unfinished firearm components such as ghost guns or printed parts 00:49:13
- The vice chair supported the staff recommendation, saying the commission routinely decides where uses are appropriate 00:50:11
- The zoning administrator said a home firearm-sales permit request today would go to the zoning administrator, reaching the commission only on appeal 00:51:02
- The chair recalled an accidental discharge at a gun store and said wood-frame houses offer little protection, favoring the ban while describing themself as a responsible gun owner 00:51:49
- The commission's counsel said a motion would be preferable to forwarding without a recommendation 00:52:48
- A commissioner voted yes, in support of barring home sales even without full information on federal rules 00:53:28
- Douglas Snell (Commissioner) voted no, saying it was unclear the ban solves a current problem 00:54:11
- David Nybo (Commissioner) voted no, calling gun sales heavily regulated and seeing no demonstrated problem 00:54:49
- A commissioner voted no, agreeing with the policy direction but saying the city must provide better information before such decisions 00:55:42
- The city clerk stated that the motion needed seven aye votes to pass 00:56:21
- The commission's counsel said the item can be forwarded to the council with the votes and the commission's comments 00:56:48
Commission's 2026 annual report Item 5
Zoning and plansPollution
The commission's annual report to the council and public on its accomplishments and priorities, forwarded to the council's Personnel and Public Employees Committee. The 2027 Planning and Zoning Work Program is attached as an appendix once the council adopts it. Discussion turned to a crematorium approved by right near an elementary school. 00:56:58
- Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) moved to forward the 2026 annual report to the Personnel and Public Employees Committee; Douglas Snell (Commissioner) seconded; Erin Reschke (Commissioner) was absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 01:14:04
- The planning director presented the second version of the report, with project numbers updated since the October 8 review 00:58:00
- The planning director said the chair's message is still being written and the work program will be added as appendix A after council action 00:58:00
- A commissioner asked whether the crematorium's by-right status comes from city or state law 01:03:30
- The planning director said crematoriums are allowed by right in the M-1 and M-2 industrial zones 01:04:00
- The planning director said a crematorium rule could be added to the comprehensive zoning code update coming to the commission in January 01:05:03
- A commissioner urged ways to notify the public or involve community associations when industrial uses locate next to homes 01:05:41
- Deborah Ortiz (Commissioner) asked what tools exist to block future crematoriums near schools 01:06:50
- The planning director said requiring a conditional use permit for crematoriums would add a discretionary review guided by environmental justice policies 01:08:50
- The planning director said a broader review of land uses and health would need data the city plans to collect starting next year 01:08:50
- Deborah Ortiz (Commissioner) expressed concern about polluting uses being concentrated in some communities and asked that this be considered in future zoning changes 01:10:25
- David Nybo (Commissioner) thanked the public speaker for well-prepared comments 01:11:04
- The vice chair moved the staff recommendation and asked staff to raise switching such uses from by right to conditional use permits in the January presentation 01:11:25
- The planning director said the annual report can move forward separately, with the work program going to Law and Legislation and then the council in late January 01:12:26
2027 Planning and Zoning Work Program Item 6
Zoning and plans
The yearly list of planning and zoning policy priorities and action items, which the council approves each year. The commission recommends it to the council, expected in late January. 01:14:26
- David Nybo (Commissioner) moved the staff recommendation to forward the 2027 Planning and Zoning Work Program to the council for approval; Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) seconded; Erin Reschke (Commissioner) was absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 01:20:11
Commissioner comments
Commissioners' closing remarks, including thanks to a commissioner whose term is ending. 01:20:20
Public comment
- One member of the public spoke on the annual report (agenda item 5) in opposition because the 2027 work program will be attached to it. They argued the work program leaves out the general plan's environmental justice policies. They cited a crematory with two incinerators approved by right in August 2025 across from D.W. Babcock School, and said pollution burden in the census tract has risen.
- The same speaker returned on the 2027 work program (agenda item 6). They argued a conditional use permit requirement would be inadequate. They said the zoning code bars crematories from many zones and near transit sites, yet one was approved about 400 feet from the school.
- During comment on matters not on the agenda, the same speaker urged the city to revoke the administrative by-right approval of two incinerators at 2445 Albatross Way before a certificate of occupancy is issued. They cited zoning code and general plan provisions.
- No members of the public spoke on the consent calendar, the Humble Root permits, or the firearm ordinance.
What's next
- The firearm and ammunition home-sales ordinance goes to the council at a future hearing. Counsel said it can be forwarded with the commission's votes and comments, and staff said the council can still adopt it.
- Staff said the insurance concern and the question of whether any incidents are tied to firearms sold legally from homes would be passed to the council.
- Staff agreed to follow up with Deborah Ortiz (Commissioner) on whether gun dealers are registering with the police department under an older city ordinance.
- The 2026 annual report goes to the council's Personnel and Public Employees Committee, then to the council.
- The 2027 Planning and Zoning Work Program goes to the Law and Legislation Committee, then to the council in late January.
- The comprehensive zoning code update comes to the commission in January. Dov Kadin (Commissioner; Vice Chair, Planning and Design Commission) (moving agenda item 5) asked staff to include whether some uses, such as crematoriums, should need a conditional use permit instead of being allowed by right.
- The Norwood Avenue applicant may reapply later with a new conditional use permit request.
- The next commission meeting is January 14.
Write to the Planning and Design Commission before its next meeting: its comment form