CivicFM
Sacramento

· 15 items

City Council, Tuesday, November 17

What happened, from the recording. The hosts take it up in Sacramento's next episode.

This episode was produced with AI from the public recordings of the week's meetings. Links to the sources are in the show notes.

What happened

City Council Tuesday, November 17

15 items

The recording · Agenda · Agenda · Agenda

International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women Item A

Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) led a presentation recognizing November 25 as the International Day for the Elimination of Violence Against Women, honoring the Sacramento County Commission on the Status of Women and Girls and a commissioner whose term is ending. 00:02:01

Sacramento Hmong New Year Item B

Mai Vang (Councilmember, District 8) and Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) presented a resolution honoring the Sacramento Hmong New Year celebration, held Thanksgiving weekend at Cal Expo, and its organizing committee. 00:18:20

City Management Academy graduation Item C

The council recognized the 37 graduates of this year's twelve-week City Management Academy, a civic education program for residents and small business owners. 00:28:54

Horse-drawn vehicles in the East Sacramento Holiday Zone (withdrawn) Item 14

Street safety

An emergency ordinance regulating horse-drawn vehicles in the East Sacramento Holiday Zone, listed on the agenda as withdrawn. It was not heard; the presiding officer said Phil Pluckebaum (Councilmember, District 4) is working with the community on a traffic management plan for the area. 00:40:36

  • Item withdrawn from the agenda; not heard. Result: withdrawn. 00:40:36
  • The presiding officer announced the horse-drawn vehicle ordinance would not be heard and said a traffic management plan is being worked out with the neighborhood 00:40:36

Short-term rental ordinance continued Item 13

Zoning and plansRenters and tenants

A public hearing on an ordinance amending city code rules on short-term rentals (City Code Chapter 5.114 and sections of Title 17). The agenda called for a two-thirds vote to close the hearing and adopt the ordinance, but the council did neither: before the consent calendar, without discussion, it voted only to continue the item to no date certain. 00:41:14

  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) moved and Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) seconded to continue the short-term rental item to a date uncertain; Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7) absent; Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) attending remotely. Result: continued, 8-0. 00:42:00

Urban Area Security Initiative grant pulled and continued Item 11

Surveillance technologyImmigrantsFederal and state funding

A resolution to apply for and accept a $3,734,739 (agenda) federal Urban Area Security Initiative subaward for the Sacramento region, and keep four grant-funded positions. It was pulled from the consent calendar and continued to no date certain. The mayor said it would get no public comment, but about six speakers objected to the grant during the consent calendar's comment period, tying it to the regional fusion center and data sharing with immigration enforcement. 00:42:08

  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) moved to continue the Urban Area Security Initiative item to no date certain; second not clearly identified; Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7) absent. Result: continued, 8-0. 00:43:07
  • The presiding officer said councilmembers had unanswered questions about how the program operates, its handling of sensitive data, and the city's values 00:42:20

Consent calendar, items 1 through 10

HomelessnessBudgetsAudits

Ten routine items approved in one vote, including the City Auditor's quarterly report, the first-quarter financial report, a $2,571,271 (agenda) contract supplement with Step Up on Second Street for homeless outreach and shelter voucher services, and several contract amendments and grants. 00:43:34

  • Motion to approve consent calendar items 1 through 10; mover and seconder not stated on the record; Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7) absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 01:11:32
  • A councilmember asked for an update on litigation involving Step Up on Second Street and on problems families have had with the hotel voucher program it runs 00:43:54

Unpaid code enforcement fees made special assessments on properties Item 12

Code enforcement

A public hearing on making unpaid code compliance fees and penalties personal obligations of property owners and special assessments on their properties. Staff said the amended list covers 502 properties and $1,081,463.85, with 10 properties removed. 01:11:58

  • Motion to close the public hearing and approve item 12; mover and seconder not clearly identified; Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7) absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 01:13:47
  • The code enforcement manager said the amended list covers 502 properties and about $1.08 million in unpaid fees and penalties, after removing 10 properties 01:12:15

Written objections to proposed water and wastewater rate increases Item 15

WaterTaxes and fees

Under a new state process, ratepayers could file formal written objections to the proposed water and wastewater rates for fiscal years starting July 1, 2027, through 2031, and the council had to accept the city's responses before the Proposition 218 protest hearing. The new rates replace the old room-count wastewater charge with a census-based charge per household type and lower the fixed share of bills from about 62% to about 50%. Objectors argued the design hurts low-water-use and low-income customers. The council accepted the responses so the protest hearing can go ahead December 2. 01:14:13

  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) moved to adopt the resolution accepting the written objections and the city's responses and proceed with the Proposition 218 protest hearing, with direction that a discussion item return to council if a court decision clarifies rate methodology; second not clearly identified; Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7) absent; Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) voted aye 'with an asterisk'. Result: passed, 8-0. 02:15:14
  • City staff said the clerk received 18 objections, 12 of them valid and timely 01:18:45
  • City staff said the responses do not recommend changing the proposed rates 01:20:48
  • City staff said the utility rate assistance program takes about 40% off bills for income-qualified customers and the department will seek more funding for it 01:22:50
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) objected that a small older home would pay the same rate as a single-family home twice its size 01:33:12
  • City staff said the old room-count rate lacked supporting data and would not hold up in court 01:35:35
  • City staff said staff chose a census-based density method over winter water use 01:36:38
  • City staff clarified that the unit rate is the same for single-family homes, not each total bill 01:40:33
  • A councilmember asked whether the council should wait for a pending state Supreme Court case on tiered water rates 01:44:31
  • The city's outside counsel on utility rates said that decision is at least a year and probably two years away, and that adopting these rates wouldn't stop the council from reexamining them later 01:45:51
  • A councilmember said the pending case leaves the council constrained 01:46:52
  • City staff said about half of each bill would be fixed charges under the new structure 01:48:57
  • A rate consultant for the city noted the fixed share is dropping from 62% to 50% 01:52:08
  • The city's outside counsel on utility rates said two appeals court rulings struck down other agencies' tiered water rates for lack of data 02:00:45
  • City staff described the utility's finances as dire after years without a rate increase 02:03:22
  • The city manager said an emergency water or sewer break would likely have to be paid from the general fund 02:03:58
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) argued for moving ahead to keep up with aging infrastructure, citing Flint, Michigan 02:11:27
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) said the council may need to put more Measure U money into rate assistance 02:11:27
  • A councilmember asked that the council be able to act, not just get a report, if courts change the law 02:14:00
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) added direction to the motion that a discussion item return if a court decision clarifies the law 02:14:30

Illegal dumping gap analysis and new cleanup group Item 16

Trash and recyclingCode enforcement

Staff's response to a council proposal on illegal dumping. It creates a pilot Recycling and Solid Waste CLEAR group (Cleanup, Legal Disposal, Enforcement, Awareness, Response) with nine new positions (agenda), adds small debris crews and more junk and appliance pickup appointments, and buys five more illegal dumping cameras for $128,500, bringing the camera contract to $468,500 (agenda). Staff said dumping cost $2.9 million in 2025 across 11,000 cases, and that no new funding was requested. 02:15:21

  • Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) moved the staff recommendations; Mai Vang (Councilmember, District 8) said she would second, and the chair stated the second as Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem); Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7) absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 02:51:57
  • A Public Works program manager said the city had 11,000 illegal dumping cases in 2025 and spent $2.9 million on collection and disposal 02:18:59
  • A Public Works program manager said a four-week field survey in May and June found about 90% of dumped piles were green waste 02:21:18
  • A Public Works program manager said only about 7% of reports include information that lets the city open a case 02:22:20
  • A Public Works program manager said dumping cameras have led to 27 citations since May 2025 02:24:31
  • A Public Works program manager said no new funding is requested; the work is paid from ratepayer funds and franchise fees, since ratepayer money can't pay for illegal dumping 02:30:14
  • A councilmember called the plan a first step and urged coordination with Community Response and code enforcement 02:36:01
  • A councilmember repeated his request that the city attorney update its Prop 218 opinion on using ratepayer money for dumping 02:37:01
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) named District 6 hotspots, including one next to an elementary school 02:40:20
  • Eric Guerra (Councilmember, District 6; Mayor Pro Tem) asked for repeated outreach in residents' own languages south of Fruitridge Road 02:41:30
  • A councilmember said no neighborhood should become a dumping ground because of past underinvestment 02:43:13
  • City staff said code officers review motion-triggered camera footage about weekly and keep footage only when building a case 02:47:08
  • City staff said the cameras black out private property and capture only the public right of way 02:49:09
  • A councilmember said her office plans to propose a citywide surveillance data retention policy 02:49:47

Police military equipment use policy renewed Item 18

Surveillance technologyPolicing

Under state law (AB 481), the police department brings its military equipment use policy and an annual report to the council each year. The agenda item adopts an ordinance renewing the policy and receives the report, which covers May 1, 2025, to April 30, 2026: equipment was used in 330 incidents, 23 of them involving use of force, with no complaints received. It proposes $186,405.32 in already-budgeted purchases, mostly drones. About 18 public speakers opposed it. The council approved it 7-1, with Mai Vang (Councilmember, District 8) voting no and Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7) absent. 02:52:20

  • Phil Pluckebaum (Councilmember, District 4) moved approval of the staff recommendation; second not identified; Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7) absent. Result: passed, 7-1. No: Mai Vang (Councilmember, District 8). 03:42:22
  • City staff said military equipment was used in 330 incidents during the reporting period 02:53:05
  • City staff said the department received no complaints about military equipment 02:54:12
  • City staff said proposed purchases total about $186,000 and are already budgeted 02:55:17
  • City staff reported that 55% of 148 community survey responses opposed the equipment use 02:55:17
  • City staff said no equipment was used to assist ICE or for immigration purposes 02:56:20
  • City staff said next year's report will show whether outside-agency assists involved a federal agency 02:57:22
  • City staff said the department will keep the report's layout rather than add itemized costs, citing length 02:58:22
  • A councilmember said the city does not need to keep funding military equipment and she would vote no 03:39:00
  • A councilmember said a no vote would force the department to stop using the equipment or revise its policy 03:40:03
  • The presiding officer said AB 481 was meant to provide transparency, not to prohibit equipment 03:40:58

Five-year Axon contract for police body cameras, license plate readers and drones Item 17

Surveillance technologyPolicingImmigrants

A five-year master agreement with Axon combining six existing contracts. It covers body-worn cameras, tasers, car cameras, fixed license plate readers, drone first responder and counter-drone systems, real-time camera integration, and more. The agenda lists up to $17,515,189 for police and $213,102 for fire through September 30, 2031. Staff put the police cost at about $17.09 million over five years, about $2.48 million more than the last contract. About 25 public speakers opposed it over surveillance and data sharing. The council approved it 6-1, with Mai Vang (Councilmember, District 8) voting no and Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7) and Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent, on the condition that a binding addendum be negotiated covering data ownership, AI training opt-out, limits on data sharing, legal compliance, and a 30-day no-penalty exit. If Axon doesn't agree, it returns to council. 03:42:50

▶ Hear it What would new guardrails add to the police tech contract? · 0:56

  • A councilmember moved to extend the meeting past 9:30 p.m.; second not identified; Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7) absent. Result: passed, 8-0. 04:00:34
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) moved to approve and authorize the City Manager to execute the Axon master services and purchasing agreement, conditioned on a binding addendum: city ownership of data with no-cost export, opt-out of AI training, retention under existing city policy pending a later council discussion, no default cross-agency or federal sharing without a verified active criminal investigation, no new AI features without council approval, express compliance with SB 34, SB 54, AB 481 and sanctuary policies with audit oversight, and 30-day termination for convenience without penalty. If Axon does not agree, the item returns to council. Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) seconded; Rick Jennings (Councilmember, District 7) and Caity Maple (Councilmember, District 5) absent. Result: passed, 6-1. No: Mai Vang (Councilmember, District 8). 05:14:04
  • City staff said the 60-month contract consolidates six Axon contracts 03:44:34
  • City staff said the bundle with extra products costs $300,000 less than buying four core products alone 03:45:39
  • City staff said a review of 96 lawsuits found body cameras helped reduce settlements or win dismissals in 16, worth $12 million 03:45:39
  • City staff said the department does not share license plate reader data with federal agencies 03:46:46
  • City staff said partner California agencies can search the city's plate data remotely through federated access 03:49:50
  • City staff said every search is logged and the department audits plate reader searches quarterly 03:48:50
  • City staff said the contract is about $2.48 million more than the last one, roughly $496,000 a year 03:51:04
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) said she reviewed the contract and found concerns about data, AI and termination valid 04:45:56
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) proposed guardrails starting with full city data ownership, free exit, and opting out of Axon AI training 04:48:01
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) proposed a right to end the contract on 30 days' notice without penalty 04:49:03
  • The city attorney said the office reviewed the proposed additions and found them appropriate 04:50:46
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) asked that access audit logs come to council publicly at least yearly 04:51:12
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) suggested asking the Attorney General's office how ICE is obtaining residents' information 04:52:14
  • The presiding officer said no one on the council supports sharing data for deportations, and cited a murder suspect caught within minutes using a plate reader 04:54:53
  • A councilmember noted police share plate reader data with other California agencies, beyond the city's control once shared 04:58:19
  • A councilmember objected to keeping residents' location data for at least two years 05:00:27
  • A councilmember said she needed more time to review the amendments and would vote no 05:01:27
  • The city attorney said the current contract does not expressly cite SB 34, SB 54 or the city's sanctuary policy 05:03:22
  • The presiding officer noted the city keeps plate data up to two years and said changing retention would need another council action 05:05:41
  • Lisa Kaplan (Councilmember, District 1) agreed to keep current retention policy for now and return later to discuss it 05:07:05
  • City staff said the department already opted out of drone AI learning and the contract requires compliance with local laws 05:09:06
  • The city attorney offered to send the council a confidential memo if all conditions are met, or bring the contract back if not 05:12:17
  • A councilmember called the 30-day termination for convenience a key protection 05:12:59

Council comments and AB 1234 reports

Homelessness

Councilmembers made announcements, including a community update on the Gardendale micro community and a travel report. 05:14:31

  • A councilmember announced a community meeting the next day with the mayor and the Department of Community Response on the Gardendale micro community 05:14:55
  • A councilmember reported plans to attend the National League of Cities conference 05:18:32

City Manager's report

Trash and recyclingWater

Reminders on leaf season pickup, the fall and winter watering schedule, and the Shop 916 holiday gift card promotion. 05:17:22

  • The city manager reminded residents that leaf season began and to fill organics bins before leaving piles for the claw 05:17:25
  • The city manager said landscape watering is now allowed once a week, on Saturday or Sunday 05:17:25

Adjournment in memory of a labor leader

The meeting adjourned at 11:28 p.m. in memory of a labor leader whose procession to the state Capitol some councilmembers attended the day before. 05:59:13

Public comment

  • Consent calendar: 10 people spoke. About six objected to the pulled Urban Area Security Initiative grant, citing data sharing through fusion centers, license plate readers, and recent ICE arrests and confrontations with protesters in Sacramento. One praised the City Auditor's report. One asked about the increase in the water regulatory support contract (item 5). One urged investment in rebuilding police-community trust.
  • During consent comment, one speaker used profanity, told the council it would regret its votes, and read aloud what they said was the mayor's home address. The clerk cut the speaker off and the presiding officer called a short recess; the meeting resumed a few minutes later.
  • Water rate objections (item 15): two people spoke. A Sierra Club representative did not oppose raising rates but said the design falls hardest on low-use, low-income customers and that the process lacked notice. Another speaker argued Proposition 218 requires more public hearings and an equity review, and asked the city to publish its federal water contract.
  • Illegal dumping (item 16): one speaker, who spoke about the security grant instead and was ruled out of order by the clerk.
  • Military equipment policy (item 18): about 18 people spoke, all opposed. They cited 72 outside-agency assistance incidents they said were not explained, proposed drone purchases, racial disparities in use of the equipment, police answers to the Community Police Review Commission they called inadequate, and rising use of flash-bangs and chemical agents. Several urged spending the money on housing and social services instead.
  • Axon contract (item 17): about 25 people spoke, all opposed. Common points: a pending California class action accusing Axon of violating SB 34 on plate data, police sharing of plate data with outside agencies including two fusion centers, the difficulty of exiting a five-year bundled contract, Axon's termination penalty and changeable vendor terms, retail theft and drone features, and spending about $17 million while the city faces a budget shortfall. Several asked the council to continue the item or not bundle the contracts.
  • Matters not on the agenda: about 18 people spoke. About seven opposed a proposed 300-megawatt data center in Depot Park and called for a citywide data center moratorium. About five asked the city to revoke a permit for a crematory with two incinerators near DW Babcock Elementary and adopt resident-drafted ordinances limiting polluting uses in disadvantaged communities. Several criticized the night's surveillance votes and the city's response to ICE. Single speakers raised the lack of a citywide ADA coordinator and inaccessible staff reports, the status of moving the Office of Violence Prevention out of the police department, a Reuters investigation of Axon, a councilmember's late arrival at a prior meeting, and the clerk's handling of a proxy speaker.

What's next

  • The short-term rental ordinance (item 13) and the Urban Area Security Initiative grant (item 11) were continued to no date certain.
  • The Proposition 218 protest hearing on water and wastewater rates is set for December 2, 2026, at the Utilities Rate Advisory Commission. Staff will bring rates to council for adoption in early 2027, effective July 1, 2027 if adopted.
  • The council directed that a discussion item return if a court decision clarifies allowable water rate methods. Staff will also seek more rate assistance program funding in the budget process.
  • Axon: the city attorney and police will negotiate a binding addendum with Axon. The city attorney will send a confidential memo if all conditions are met; otherwise the contract returns to council. A separate council discussion of license plate data retention is expected.
  • Mai Vang (Councilmember, District 8) said her office will submit a citywide surveillance technology data retention policy.
  • Roger Dickinson (Councilmember, District 2) asked the city attorney to revisit its Proposition 218 opinion on using ratepayer money for illegal dumping work.
  • Police said next year's military equipment report will show whether outside-agency assists involved a federal agency.
  • Phil Pluckebaum (Councilmember, District 4) is working with the community on a traffic management plan for the East Sacramento Holiday Zone after the horse-drawn vehicle ordinance was withdrawn.
  • A community update on the Gardendale micro community was announced for the next day, 6 to 7:30 p.m., at Martin Luther King Library.

Write to the City Council before its next meeting: its comment form

Every claim is checked against the recording and documents linked above. Report an error